In this article, you will see the 30 best Italian foods in New York. Italian foods are foods that consist of ingredients, recipes, and cooking techniques developed in Italy. Please note that all Italian foods are spicy and tasty, but in addition to that, this article will use other rating criteria such as professionalism, friendly environment, good customer service, helpfulness, etc. to bring you the best ones that will give you value for your money.
30 Best Italian Foods in New York City New Me
Below are the best Italian Foods in New York City. They already enjoy 4.0+ star reviews on Google places and other top directory websites in the US.
1. Risotteria Melotti NYC
The Melotti Family has been producing the best varieties of Italian rice since 1986. It produces the Vialone Nano Rice and Carnaroli Rice varieties which grow thanks to spring water and organic soils.
In the family business, located in Isola della Scala in Verona, in northern Italy, Giuseppe Melotti and his wife Rosetta, together with their children Luca, Gianmaria and Francesca directly follow the cultivation, the processing and the sale of their rice.
Address: 309 E 5th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
Reservations: risotteriamelottinyc.com, opentable.com
Order: risotteriamelottinyc.com, seamless.com, grubhub.com, postmates.com, ubereats.com
Phone: +1 646-755-8939
See Also: 15 Best Street Food in New York
2. Masseria dei Vini
Masseria dei Vini (Masseria of Wines) is brought to you by the La Masseria team. Restaurateurs Pino Coladonato, Peppe Iuele and Enzo Ruggiero have collaborated again with interior design expert Libby Langdon to bring you a modern and updated version of a “Masseria”. In the region of Puglia, in Southern Italy, masserias are fortified farmhouses, and many of them have now been transformed into restaurants or hotels.
Executive Chef Pino Coladonato, native of Rutigliano (Bari), has created a menu that blends traditional with modern without overpowering one or the other. The menu features beautiful dishes from Puglia, a lot of which incorporate fish, shellfish and a plethora of fresh homemade pastas. The menu offers gourmet pizza Neapolitan style from a Ferrara wood-burning pizza oven and also offered is an extensive wine by the glass program and a large selection of bottles, mainly from Italy, but without ignoring the rest of the world.
Order: grubhub.com, bbot.menu, seamless.com
Phone: +1 212-315-2888
3. IL Gattopardo
Il Gattopardo serves traditional Southern Italian comfort food that has been adapted for the contemporary palate without compromising the authenticity of the cuisine, which became a must to its loyal upscale New Yorker clientele. They are committed to producing top quality Southern Italian gastronomy, to the use of authentic ingredients, and to keeping the tradition of Italian culture, and hospitality, vibrant and passionate.
Address: 13-15 W 54th St, New York, NY 10019, United States
Providers Order: ilgattopardonyc.com
Providers Phone: +1 212-246-0412
4. Osteria Morini
Osteria Morini brings the soulful cuisine and convivial spirit of Emilia-Romagna in northern Italy to Manhattan’s vibrant SoHo neighborhood. Known as the Italian Breadbasket, this region is also the birthplace of some of the flavors and ingredients most commonly associated with Italian cuisine worldwide: prosciutto, mortadella, parmigiano, and balsamic vinegar.
In Italian, “osteria” means a place where the owner “hosts” guests. The 98-seat restaurant, located on Petrosino Square, offers dinner and weekend brunch.
Osteria Morini dismantled and shipped components from an Italian 1700s-era farmhouse to create the unique décor. The semi-open kitchen allows for guests to watch the action of their meal preparation unfold. Executive Chef Bill Dorrler oversees the kitchen operations at Osteria Morini, led daily by Chef di Cucina Gerardo Fernandez. Osteria Morini’s wine list was curated to include wines native to this part of Italy.
Address: 218 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10012
Areas served: Soho and nearby areas
Reservations: sevenrooms.com, resy.com
Providers Phone: (212) 965-8777
5. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio
Siciliy’s island status means inundation from seas on all sides, which is where much of the restaurant’s ingredients will be sourced. A stationary Piaggio Ape—which visitors to Italy will recognize as the mini delivery trucks bearing down on them on the country’s tinier streets—displays the fresh catch of the day and guests can opt for their selection grilled, fried or broiled.
Raw fish (Italy’s now ubiquitous “crudos”) include a passion fruit-marinated salmon tartare and a carpaccio made with yellowtail topped with orange and fennel. Simply prepared fish fritto like calamari and shrimp, plus grilled octopus, sardines and fish skewers, complete the seafood appetizers. Don’t sleep on the arancino catanese (riceballs); Sicilians do these very well.
Address: 75 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012
Phone: (646) 781-9183
L’Artusi presents a modern take on traditional Italian cuisine, combining comfort and creativity.
Their wine program features a mostly Italian wine list, presented by region with a map of DOCs and DOCGs accompanied by traditional local dishes, helping to demystify Italy, the most diverse viticultural nation in the world.
Their 110 seat restaurant, features two floors of comfortable banquette seating, extended traditional bar, cheese bar and a chef’s counter overlooking the open kitchen. Private dining opportunities are also available in our 2500 bottle walk-in wine cellar.
Address: 228 W 10th St, New York, NY 10014
Providers Phone: (212) 255-5757
7. Altro Paradiso
Altro Paradiso is an Italian restaurant in the heart of SoHo and an essential New York City dining destination. The restaurant’s menu draws inspiration from several Italian regions, celebrating timeless craftsmanship throughout, while the room’s high ceilings and glimmering brass bar contribute to a lively nightly atmosphere. Since opening in 2016, Altro has garnered many devoted regulars, ranging from neighborhood residents to travelers who treat the restaurant like a second home whenever they’re in town.
8. Locanda Verde
Locanda Verde is their TriBeCa neighborhood taverna serving Chef Andrew Carmellini’s soul-satisfying urban Italian menu.
Their bustling corner restaurant has been welcoming New Yorkers morning, noon and night since 2009 with a warm and comfortable atmosphere, leisurely Italian spirit and heartfelt cooking.
Located in: The Greenwich Hotel
Address: 377 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10013
Providers Phone: (212) 925-3797
Here at Amici they serve only the best homemade Italian dishes from Napoli in New York City’s Little Italy. Come try their classic recipes, fresh ingredients, and bold Italian flavors! Amici means friends and over the decades our customers have become just that! As a result, a high percentage of their business is from repeat customers and referrals. They would like to thank you all!
Address: 165 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (212) 203-2766
Their mission at Pisticci is to get everyone to take that first step, and then inspire them to keep on walking.
Pisticci Restaurant has always been about more than just food. Fifteen years ago they recognized the power of small business to fuel positive social change through community action, and they began leading their customers and staff, one at a time, through the door of environmental sustainability.
Address: 125 La Salle St, New York, NY 10027
Phone: (212) 932-3500
11. Toscana 49
They offer classic Italian dishes, and fresh homemade pastas that are made daily in their own kitchen, using time-honored traditional methods.
Their welcoming staff is ready to assist you in choosing wines from their extensive wine list, introducing you to their specials, which change daily to include the freshest ingredients available from local markets, or mixing you the perfect cocktail.
Located in: Best Western Plus Hospitality House
Address: 143 E 49th St, New York, NY 10017
Providers Phone: (212) 256-0190
12. La Lanterna di Vittorio
La Lanterna di Vittorio is a beautiful Italian restaurant with a cozy fireplace and a dining room lit by lanterns that doubles as a garden. A nice wine list and live jazz at night makes La Lanterna di Vittorio the perfect spot for a romantic date. The menu at La Lanterna di Vittorio lives up to the atmosphere, with excellent soups, salads, pizzas, calzones, paninis and more. Try a salad with smoked duck breast and balsamic vinaigrette, or a “salame” and melted Gorgonzola panini splashed with grappa. Share the goose liver mousse and some cheese if you are feeling adventurous. Finish your meal off with espresso and gelato, pie or decadent millefoglie, a layered dessert that is absolutely delicious.
Address: 129 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012
Reservations: lalanternacaffe.com, resy.com
Providers Phone: (917) 639-3236
13. Monte’s Trattoria
Monte’s features an assortment of the most delicious Italian cuisine around, prepared fresh daily by their chef and owner Pietro Mosconi. Taste any of the superb homemade pasta and seafood specialties while you sip on a great cocktail from their bar. For dessert, be sure to ask Rocco to make you a perfect cappuccino while you dig into their homemade Torta di Ricotta (cheesecake).
Address: 97 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012
Reservations: resy.com, opentable.com
Providers Phone: (212) 674-9456
14. OLIO E PIÙ
OLIO E PIÙ brings Italian tradition to the vibrant intersection where Sixth and Greenwich avenues meet Christopher Street, in the heart of Greenwich Village. First opened in the summer of 2010, the 74-seat restaurant fronted with a 45-seat open patio surrounded by flowers and greenery, overlooking the magnificent Jefferson Market Library. OLIO E PIÙ offers a true sense of Mediterranean liveliness in the heart of Greenwich Village.
As an authentic trattoria, its cuisine is based on classic Italian dishes, with a focus on house-made pastas, hand-stretched pizza, and time-honored favorites such as Caprese salad, fritto misto, and tiramisu. The open dining area, traditional wood-fired oven, rustic interior, thin-crust Neapolitan-style pizza, and carefully selected wine and cocktail list bring a piece of old-world Italy to a renowned corner in the Village.
Consistent with its aim of offering Italian cuisine in all its regional glory, OLIO E PIÙ takes great pride in its pasta offerings, from stuffed and noodle-based pasta to gnocchi. The lineup changes according to the season, but carbonara and tagliatelle Bolognese are on the menu year-round as guest favorites.
Address: 3 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10014
Providers Phone: (212) 243-6546
At Marea, the authentic, bracing flavors of coastal Italy meet the style and swagger of New York to form a new kind of gusto. Marea charts the tide for restaurant culture, with exquisite food and unmatched service that set the stage for an experience like no other. An anchor of Central Park and New York City icon, Marea attracts those who don’t chase luxury, but who live it-by elevating life’s moments, indulging their senses, and celebrating every day with the best food, service, and surroundings in the world.
Address: 240 Central Park S, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (212) 582-5100
Thanks to deep researching and studying, our mission is to be the most authentic and delicious Italian food, made with the best ingredients in the world and paired with the best Italian wine and champagne, our wine list carries 450+ labels and is growing more.
Address: 621 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, United States
Phone: +1 347-536-1335
Located in the heart and soul of New York City—Sottocasa Harlem is owned and operated by husband and wife duo, Elena and Matteo. With a passion and love for pizza stemming back to their native Italy, Harlem now has it’s own Napoli serving up authentic Neapolitan pizza and amore!
Address: 227 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY 10027, United States
Updated by this business 5 weeks ago
Phone: +1 646-928-4870
18. Spaghetti Incident
This popular Italian street food is a thin Italian flatbread typically prepared in the Emilia Romagna region in Italy. There is a virtually infinite variety of recipes, either passed down from generation to generation or perhaps reinterpreted following the more modern techniques of international cuisine.
Address: 302 W 37th St, New York, NY 10018, United States
Providers Order: nonsolopiadanyc.com, slicelife.com, seamless.com, grubhub.com, doordash.com, postmates.com, ubereats.com
Providers Phone: +1 212-216-0616
19. Via Carota
Their Village trattoria is thoughtfully renovated: wooden floors reclaimed from an old gymnasium, vintage chapel chairs from England and rustic wooden cabinets filled with heirloom china. Servers wear crisp white shirts and long linen aprons, there are communal tables and even a private room tucked away amongst the wine bottles
Address: 51 Grove St, New York, NY 10014, United States
Order: viacarota.com, trycaviar.com
Phone: +1 212-255-1962
Rubirosa is a family-run, Italian-American, neighborhood restaurant and pizzeria.
In addition to their famous pizza, they proudly offer Italian-American classics featuring a wide array of pastas made fresh in-house daily.
Rubirosa is located in the heart of Nolita and its clientele bridges the gap between the old and new neighborhood regulars. Rubirosa’s homey and comfortable atmosphere welcomes every occasion, from family-style group dining to drinks and antipasti at they cozy bar.
Address: 235 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012, United States
Phone: +1 212-965-0500
Order: doordash.com, toasttab.com
At Norma you’ll find authentic Sicilian dishes, exclusively Sicilian wine and an atmosphere transporting you to the soul of Sicily. With a mission to bring true culture to America, Norma focuses on traditional cuisine, familial service and an intimate ambiance.
The rustic, casual elegance and exquisite, time-honored food and wine will leave you feeling at home, at Norma.
Address: 438 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States
Order: postmates.com, seamless.com, grubhub.com, toasttab.com, ubereats.com
Providers Phone: +1 212-889-0600
22. La Nonna
La Nonna features a casual and friendly dining experience where the Italian food is plentiful and delicious. Their commitment is to providing devoted, highly-personalized service as well as distinctive menus that use the finest ingredients available! They hope to see you soon at La Nonna and know you’ll enjoy the food just like your grandma’s!
Address: 134 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013, United States
Reservations: lanonnaristorante.com, opentable.com
Phone: +1 212-334-6200
MISIRIZZI is committed to having fresh homemade pasta and wine program in a cozy and house-like venue with sleek interiors an approachable, casual‐cool vibe, re-inventing the concept of family-restaurant in the NOHO neighborhood.
Address: 36 E 4th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
Reservations: resy.com, misirizzi.nyc
Providers Order: seamless.com, trycaviar.com, grubhub.com, doordash.com, ubereats.com, postmates.com
Providers Phone: +1 212-375-0100
24. Bocca Cucina and Bar
In addition to iconic Roman classics such as the tonnarelli cacio e pepe, pappardelle al ragu di agnello, and homemade pastas, Bocca seasonally updates dishes to refelct the flavors of spring-summer, as well as autum and winter, using the freshest produce from the Green Market at Union Square.
The all-Italian wine list features a broad selection of wines carefully selected to include wines made from indigenous grapes from Italy that are not mainstream. You’ll always find something different that you may not have discovered before on the wine list.
Address: 39 E 19th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
Reservations: boccanyc.com, resy.com
Providers Order: boccanyc.com, grubhub.com, trycaviar.com, seamless.com, order.online
Providers Phone: +1 212-387-1200
Their food is centered around our wood fired grill and oven down to their craft cocktails.
They’ve proudly created their pizza using no commercial yeast and handmade mozzarella. Our antipasto is a must with Casella prosciutto speciale, their mozzarella made in house, hand pulled, and served warm à la minute.
Address: 26 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States
Reservations: baranobk.com, resy.com
Providers Order: trycaviar.com, doordash.com
Providers Phone: +1 347-987-4500
26. San Matteo
San Matteo Pizza & Espresso Bar has been a Slice partner for years, providing delivery and takeout in the community. Curbside pickup at San Matteo Pizza & Espresso Bar makes things easy. Place an order, and it’ll be ready for you to pick up at your convenience. Thanks to its multiple locations, it’s easy to find a San Matteo Pizza & Espresso Bar location to serve you. Wherever you are, you can find a branch near you. Save yourself some money with one of the regular deals at San Matteo Pizza & Espresso Bar. It’s a great way to make your dollars stretch further.
27. Lido Harlem Restaurant
Named after Lido di Venezia, the famous beach in Italy, the playground of film stars, fashion icons, The Venice Film Festival and of course, Josephine Baker in her heyday.
The food is memorably delicious, and the atmosphere is elegant but convivial. Their guests say they feel as if they’re at the home of a charming Italian friend.
Address: 2168 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, NY 10026, United States
Providers Order: ubereats.com, postmates.com
Providers Phone: +1 646-490-8575
28. Aunt Jakes
Aunt Jakes’ core mission is to bring high-quality fresh ingredients daily to craft their handmade pasta and sauces in a health-conscious manner. The customer can mix and match, sauce with shape, and create a custom dish of their own.
Service options: Dine-in · Curbside pickup · No-contact delivery
Address: 133 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013
Providers Phone: (646) 858-0470
Dell’anima moved to Hell’s Kitchen in Gotham West Market just a few blocks away from Times Square on 44th Street and 11th Avenue. dell’anima can accommodate up to 22 guests at their signature Chef’s Counter, where guests dine front row with Chef Andrew. When the weather cooperates, grab a seat along their sidewalk, at one of the 10 outdoor bar seats. For those looking for a table, communal seating is always available throughout Gotham West Market, where they happily offer full hospitality. Seats are always available for walk-ins to enjoy a glass of wine and/or eat a whole meal. Whether you’re looking to grab a beer after work, eat a panini during your lunch break, carbo load after a day walking the high line or at the intrepid, or have an intimate and exciting culinary experience
Service options: Dine-in · Takeout · Delivery
Located in: Gotham West
Address: 600 11th Ave, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 366-6633
30. Original Vincent’s
Original Vincent’s is proud to have preserved the secret of the ancient recipe and to be able to serve you for your enjoyment!
Service options: Dine-in · Takeout · Delivery
Address: 119 Mott St, New York, NY 10013
Phone: (212) 226-8133